Is it a good idea to “update” an old article for SEO purposes?

Many companies and businesses looking to improve their website’s or online store’s search engine optimization (SEO) often use a content strategy that involves publishing blog articles. However, some companies choose to “update” previously published articles rather than creating new ones. This raises the question: Is it a good idea to “update” an old article for SEO purposes? In this article, I will try to answer that question.

The difference between updating and rewriting or replacing

It is important to note that, when it comes to blog posts, there is a significant distinction between updating an article and rewriting or replacing it:

Updating an article

Updating an article involves adding information about a specific topic. This is considered a valid update when done in one of the following ways:

– Adding one or two “additional” paragraphs at the end of the article.

– Correcting specific phrases or paragraphs within the article.

Updating an article is a normal practice—especially when part of the content has changed significantly, making an update necessary to keep the information current.

Rewriting or replacing an article

Rewriting or replacing an article occurs when the entire (or nearly the entire) content is changed, to the point where the original text is either minimal or completely gone. While an update might retain 80% to 100% of the original content, a rewrite or replacement might retain only 0% to 20% of the original material.

Is it a good idea to "update" an old article for SEO purposes?

Justification for the change

Any such change (update) must be well justified. For instance, if an article covers news within your sector, it might genuinely require an update—especially if it relates to a specific date or if new, relevant information has emerged. Conversely, updating an article without a clear justification could easily be flagged as a “black hat” SEO tactic.

Why does Google dislike rewritten or replaced articles?

Rewriting or replacing articles hinders Google’s ability to provide high-quality, reliable search results. This makes perfect sense: it prevents a website focused on a specific topic from “drastically” altering its information without prior notice. For example, imagine you are Google and you’ve ranked an article about physical therapy. If that article suddenly changes its content—shifting from physical therapy to, say, online gambling—without any warning, would that website remain a reliable source in Google’s eyes? The answer is likely no.

Personal and professional experience on the subject

In my own professional experience, I generally advise against modifying old articles unless it is strictly necessary. Most of the time, when you alter older content, it ends up losing its SEO ranking. For example, many of my clients—noticing that certain old blog posts were performing well in search—would ask: “Why don’t we add a marketing message or promote an event in this old post to take advantage of its traffic?” The problem is that changing the content usually leads to two outcomes: the article’s SEO growth stalls, and it subsequently begins to lose its search ranking. For this reason, I don’t recommend modifying old articles unless the changes are minor and absolutely essential.

What are your thoughts on this? Do you update your old blog posts?

If you would like to learn more about search engine optimization (SEO), I recommend my course titled “SEO and AEO Course for Service-Based Businesses” (100% legitimate SEO). For more information, visit the following link.

Leave a Comment